Choosing an RO recovery rate without scaling the membrane
How recovery drives concentrate quality, and why pushing it higher trades water for scaling risk.
The engineering question
A higher recovery means more product water. What does it cost you, and where is the limit set by the membrane rather than by the pump?
Worked example
The figures below were produced by running the RO Recovery Calculator with the same inputs .
These figures are worked by the published method rather than executed at build time, because this tool is a self-contained page calculator without a programmatic engine.
- Permeate flow is feed flow multiplied by the recovery fraction.
- Concentrate is the remainder, and its concentration is what sets the scaling risk.
- Antiscalant dosing and acid treatment extend the range but cannot remove it.
Sanity check
Permeate plus concentrate must equal the feed exactly. If it does not, a flow has been lost between the two.
Tools for this problem
These are the EngiMetric calculators that compute the numbers in this topic. Each one shows its formula, its units and its limits rather than returning a bare result.
- RO Recovery Calculator RO recovery and permeate flow with full water and salt balance closure, concentrate concentration and salt loads.
- RO Scaling Risk & Pretreatment Analysis Screen CaCO3 scaling risk in RO feed and concentrate using the Langelier Saturation Index (ASTM D3739) and the Stiff & Davis Stability Index (S&DSI) for high-TDS and seawater feeds.
- RO Concentrate Flow Calculator Brine/reject flow with water and salt balance closure, concentrate TDS, concentration factor and salt loads.
Engineering review required
This topic supports professional engineering work; it does not replace a sealed design. The result depends on site data, the governing standard and engineering judgement, and should be confirmed by a competent engineer before it is built.
References & standards
- DOWEX — RO membrane design guidelines
- Hydranautics — membrane system design
- Energy Recovery — ERD sizing
Related problems
What salt rejection means for permeate quality
Relating feed concentration, rejection percentage and permeate salinity, and reading the recovery calculator correctly.
Also: Chemical & Process
Choosing pretreatment so the membranes survive
Matching filtration and dosing decisions to the fouling and scaling risk of the raw water.
Also: Chemical & Process